One plus one equals one...
Q=q uestioner. JWA=Jehovah's Witness Answer. CA=Christian answer) I Corinthians 8:6. “… there is but one God, the Father, from whom are all things, and we [exist] for Him… and one Lord, Jesus Christ, by whom are all things… and we [exist] through Him.”
Q. How many Gods are there?
JWA. There is one Almighty God, and His Son Jesus is also a god, but not at the Almighty level.
Q. Sounds like you are saying “two” gods. But this passage says there is only one.
JWA. But did you note that this passage marks a difference between the one God and the one Lord? They are two separate entities, according to Paul.
Q. Yes, this is why we are looking at this verse. I’ll tell you even more. The translators have actually added a word, two times. The word “exist.” Your translation of course omits that. This is one time the tables are turned. What do you say about that?
JWA. We have tried to be consistent with our translating. If a word is not in the original, we should not add it, should we?
Q. Indeed. Yet we have pointed out several times when the NWT has done just that to prove JW doctrine. Let’s put that aside for the moment and examine this text. All things come from the Father. All things for us, would you not say?
JWA. Yes, that is fair. God has supplied everything we need.
Q. Therefore, says Paul, “we for Him.” He is for us, and we are for Him. He supplies everything for us, we [exist] for Him. Not really a stretch, is it? Then, everything was created by Jesus, says Paul. As in John 1:1-2. All things were made by/through Him (the Word.) And we too, are made by Him. We are kept by Him. We live through Him. We [exist] in Him. It makes perfect Biblical sense, and is enhanced by the addition of “exist”, not hurt in any way. We could leave it out, and most readers would still see what is being said. Many of the older Bibles, including one that you used at one time, the King James, leaves “exist” out. But we digress, don’t we? The question is, are there two separate entities mentioned in this passage, or only one, with two Persons?
Tell me, are you for both Jehovah and Jesus? And are you existing, living in both Jehovah and Jesus? Does one exclude the other?
CA: No, not at all. To say that I exist through Jesus is only to acknowledge that it was through Him, the Word, that God created the world. I do not exist any less through the Father because I exist through the Son. In the beginning God created and by Him , the Word, were all things created. No contradiction, no confusion. These two statements of Paul become nothing more than the old Hebrew parallelism whereby a single truth is stated in two parallel methods.
And Brother Thomas made it even easier to explain this dual statement when He simply cried out to Jesus, “My Lord and my God.”
Our Blog
-- recent blog posts -- 09/01/2024 - Pastors Timothy and Titus? 06/29/2024 - What's In a Name? 06/26/2024 - Did Agabus Make a Mistake? 05/20/2024 - Job notes for 5-20-24, Job 3:16-26 05/18/2024 - Job notes for 5-18-24. 3:1-19 05/17/2024 - Job Notes for 5-17-24. Job 2:9-13 05/16/2024 - Job4. Notes for 5-16-24, Job 2:1-8 05/15/2024 - Questions About His Coming 05/15/2024 - Job notes for 5-15-24, 1:13-22 05/14/2024 - Hearing the Truth from God 05/14/2024 - Job notes for 5-14-24, Job 1:6-12 05/13/2024 - Are you one of those...? 05/12/2024 - Job Notes, 5-13-24, Job 1:1-5 01/09/2024 - What is the "New Song"? 12/31/2023 - Encounter with God or entertainment for... 12/26/2023 - Just suppose I marry a pastor... 12/24/2023 - Stand up and shout it! 11/21/2023 - Do you have the HACKBERRY APP? 08/11/2023 - 3rd edition, "The Scroll of Revelation" 06/02/2023 - New book! 01/25/2023 - In Case You Were Wondering... the... 01/25/2023 - The Hackberry Chronicles, Volumes 11... 01/24/2023 - Number 10. The Hackberry Chronicles 01/21/2023 - Another in the Chronicles series,... 01/19/2023 - Volume VIII of Hackberry Chronicles 01/17/2023 - Volume VII now available 01/15/2023 - The Hackberry Chronicles, Volume VI 01/13/2023 - Chronicles, Volume V 01/11/2023 - Volume IV 01/09/2023 - Volume III now available 01/07/2023 - The Hackberry Chronicles, Volume II 01/05/2023 - The Hackberry Chronicles, Volume I 12/30/2022 - Back to work 10/02/2022 - Imminence. Jesus comes at any minute? 08/26/2022 - Why the Church? 08/08/2022 - New Book 06/16/2022 - There's still a MILLENNIUM! 05/26/2022 - AUDIOS and PDF of The OLIVET DISCOURSE 05/08/2022 - NEW BOOK 03/20/2022 - Not all have faith, conclusion to my... 01/29/2022 - Slain in the Spirit? Really? 01/21/2022 - AUDIO UPDATE for HACKBERRY HOUSE 12/11/2021 - The "Scroll of Revelation" (2003)... 10/19/2021 - NEW BOOK! A Study of HEBREWS available... 10/11/2021 - Scary Truth from a "Diet" book 10/05/2021 - Mega church: How many commandments... 10/04/2021 - And finally: STEP 10 for the building... 10/03/2021 - Step 9 in making that GREAT, BIG... 10/01/2021 - Want a huge assembly? Here's step... 09/30/2021 - Step 7 in the building of a... 09/29/2021 - Step 6 for a successful church: Are you... 09/28/2021 - Step 5 in that successful church plant:... 09/27/2021 - The Lord's day? Or the Lord's hour? How... 09/26/2021 - Finest Church in the City: Here's Step... 09/24/2021 - Finest Church in the City! Step 2 on... 09/23/2021 - Finest Church in the City! 09/17/2021 - NEW STUDY on JUDE has begun! Great time... 08/17/2021 - Jesus and Politics? I don't think so... 08/16/2021 - Of Heroes 08/15/2021 - How the Galatians Broke Paul's Heart 08/13/2021 - When Should You Leave Your Church? 08/12/2021 - Come out of the world, worldly... 08/03/2021 - Me 'n music 07/28/2021 - Is the Lord's Prayer still OK, Pope... 07/27/2021 - Tempted? or Tested? 07/26/2021 - Why question the Humanity of Jesus the... 07/25/2021 - Was Jesus truly man? Or, What is the... 07/23/2021 - About my article collection 07/20/2021 - Just askin'... 2. Does it really matter... 07/19/2021 - Bob's You Tube Channel 07/19/2021 - Just Askin': Nakedness at the beach. 07/15/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Conclusion 07/14/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Following 07/13/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. Death, burial...... 07/12/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad on end-time events 07/09/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: One True Religion 07/08/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: The Reward 07/07/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Anger 07/06/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. The judge? 07/05/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad, regarding sickness 07/02/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad, regarding love. 07/01/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: what about the... 06/30/2021 - Visit Brother Bob at YOUTUBE 06/30/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Response to sin 06/29/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Sin and character 06/28/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. Battle record. 06/25/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: How they... 06/24/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Monument builder... 06/23/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. The Flight. The... 06/22/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. How they maintain... 06/21/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Transfiguration... 06/18/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad, on Heaven and Hell 06/17/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Opposition 06/16/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Their ultimate... 06/15/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Their disciples 06/14/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Miracles 06/11/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. What about worship? 06/10/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad compared: the... 06/09/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: Marriage comparison? 06/08/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad, Identified by God... 06/07/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad, the formative years. 06/04/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. Annunciation and... 06/03/2021 - Temple or Kabah? 06/02/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad: The setting 06/01/2021 - Jesus and Muhammad. The genealogies... 05/31/2021 - Muhammad's genealogy compared to Jesus' 05/28/2021 - TWO NEW BOOKS! 05/28/2021 - Who did the Prophets see? Jesus... not... 05/27/2021 - JESUS, The Eternal One. Muhammad, The... 05/26/2021 - Jesus: First, Best, Last. The book,... 05/24/2021 - Who Is Jesus? Gentle Shepherd... 05/21/2021 - God's true "witnesses" know that Jesus... 05/20/2021 - Who is Jesus? Not who that false... 05/19/2021 - Who is Jesus? Not what the "prophet" of... 05/18/2021 - Who is Jesus? The Savior! 05/17/2021 - Who is Jesus? SON OF MAN 05/14/2021 - Jesus is GOD THE SON. Part 2, John... 05/13/2021 - Jesus is GOD THE SON 05/12/2021 - Jesus is THE SON OF GOD 05/11/2021 - Who is JESUS? 05/10/2021 - So who is the antichrist really? Did... 05/09/2021 - Ezekiel FOUR is now available! 05/07/2021 - Does Paul identify the antichrist? 05/05/2021 - SERIOUS clues in Revelation 17 05/04/2021 - A resurrected ruler. John and Daniel... 05/03/2021 - The antichrist in Revelation 13: the... 04/30/2021 - What? Not just a TYPE? Is he coming... 04/29/2021 - ANTIOCHUS EPIPHANES? Why not? 04/28/2021 - Daniel 11 is a KEY to who is the... 04/27/2021 - Daniel 9, Part Two of the "70 sevens"... 04/26/2021 - Daniel 9 and the antichrist 04/22/2021 - Daniel 8 and the antichrist. Part 3.... 04/21/2021 - Daniel 8 and the antichrist, part 2. 04/20/2021 - Antichrist in Daniel 8? 04/19/2021 - Matthew 24 Commentary, conclusion. 04/16/2021 - SPEAK MY LANGUAGE Revisited by a... 04/15/2021 - Matthew 24, Commentary, Part 3 04/14/2021 - Matthew 24 Commentary: part 2. 04/13/2021 - Matthew 24, a commentary, part one 04/12/2021 - NEW BOOK! Ezekiel Part Three! 04/09/2021 - Who is the Antichrist? Introduction... 04/08/2021 - Who is the antichrist? INTRODUCTION 04/06/2021 - The Rapture: A Summary 04/05/2021 - The rapture. Responding to that "wrath"... 04/02/2021 - What happened in John 4:1? (The worst... 04/01/2021 - Didn't God promise "Philadelphia" to... 03/31/2021 - Come Lord Jesus! Proper prayer for a... 03/30/2021 - Even MORE distinctions between rapture... 03/29/2021 - Other "distinctions" between "rapture"... 03/28/2021 - Is the "rapture" really different from... 03/25/2021 - IMMINENCE, PART 2. Let's teach the... 03/25/2021 - NEW BOOK! Ezekiel PART TWO now... 03/24/2021 - Don't we at least know the season of... 03/23/2021 - Matthew 24... part 2 03/22/2021 - Matthew 24. SO CLEAR! "After" is the... 03/19/2021 - Two clear Scriptures about the... 03/18/2021 - In search of: PRETRIB RAPTURE... but... 03/17/2021 - Has the church always believed in a... 03/16/2021 - Rapture, Tribulation.... definitions 03/15/2021 - Yes, rapture study is Important! 03/14/2021 - Caught up! But when? The rapture of the... 03/09/2021 - RESET 4, the GREATEST RESET of ALL:... 03/07/2021 - Ezekiel saw it! The GREATER RESET! 03/07/2021 - NEW study guide available. 03/04/2021 - What will the GREATER RESET look like? 03/03/2021 - Sheep and Goat (Nations) 03/02/2021 - The Beast of Revelation 03/01/2021 - The Union for the Mediterranean: Rome... 02/28/2021 - Dominion Theology and the New World... 02/25/2021 - Prophesying out of their own spirits... 02/24/2021 - Rome and the New World Order 02/23/2021 - The reset IS coming! 02/22/2021 - New World Order. As close as your... 02/21/2021 - Reset and Genesis 02/18/2021 - What do you mean, "reset"? 02/16/2021 - Charles Spurgeon's "Free Grace." 02/15/2021 - The marks of Christ 02/14/2021 - Bearing one another's burdens... 02/11/2021 - Lusts of the flesh vs fruit of the... 02/10/2021 - Paul warns the Galatians. 02/09/2021 - Fallen from grace? Is it possible? 02/08/2021 - Moses vs the Spirit, bond vs free 02/04/2021 - Sons of God! (Galatians 4) 02/02/2021 - Enter the schoolmaster... 02/01/2021 - Christ becomes a CURSE for us. 01/29/2021 - Word Pictures from MY Romania 01/29/2021 - Did you receive the Spirit by keeping... 01/28/2021 - Does Paul agree with James in his... 01/27/2021 - The Jerusalem Council, A.D. 49 01/26/2021 - About church councils 01/25/2021 - Paul and Luther: Only God can change... 01/24/2021 - ZOOM Men's Meeting Saturdays at 7 pm... 01/22/2021 - Paul preaches the Gospel at Antioch of... 01/21/2021 - The Galatians are deserting Christ! 01/20/2021 - The letter to the Galatians 01/19/2021 - Spurgeon: Dead men know nothing. But... 01/18/2021 - Some obvious truths about Bible... 01/15/2021 - A trip through the KJV New Testament,... 01/14/2021 - Let Westcott speak for himself. 01/13/2021 - What part did Catholic priest ERASMUS...
Older
Newer
Top