THE RIGHT OF CIVIL RESISTANCE (AGAINST TYRANTS), COVENANTING AND ICONOCLASM IN REFORMATION THOUGHT
One of the most radical French expressions of the right of resistance was that voiced by Phillipe du Plessis-Mornay in his Vindiciae contra tyrannos (1579) (commonly know in English as A Defense of Liberty Against Tyrants [this rare book is available on SWRB's Puritan Hard Drive ] - ed.). Julian H. Franklin has said that Mornay was not a theologian trying to soothe conscientious doubts, "but a soldier and a statesman exhorting to revolt." Still, Franklin himself is willing to admit that Mornay is more militant than Beza when it comes to considering the issue of resistance on religious as opposed to strictly political grounds. Mornay does not let resistance depend on constitutional history or public law, as Viret and Beza did, but rather upon a general assumption that every government has an overriding religious obligation to maintain in all cases, and that if this obligation is breached anywhere, then the ruler can be deposed by his people . Mornay addresses this issue in the first question of the Vindiciae , where he asks, "Are subjects bound to obey princes if their orders contradict the law of God? " His answer explains the contractual agreement among God, rulers, and the people in feudal terms: If the vassal does not keep the fealty he swore, his fief is forfeited and he is legally deprived of all prerogatives. So also with the king. If he neglects God, if he goes over to His enemies and is guilty of felony towards God, his kingdom is forfeited of right and is often lost in fact. Mornay extends this obligation to all nations, regardless of their constitutional history, basing his argument on what is commonly referred to as "covenant theology": The people and the king enter a covenant with God to maintain proper order, including, of course, proper order in worship. Each individual, as well as the king, is responsible for seeing that his covenant is fulfilled. The importance of the worship issue for Mornay's covenant theory becomes apparent when he tries to provide a historical example. Mornay uses the case of King Josiah, indicating that the covenant between God and the Jews stipulated that "the king and his entire people would worship God according to the prescription of His Law (i.e. the regulative principle of worship —ed.) as individuals and would act collectively to protect their worship." Moreover, Mornay is not content with merely using this ancient covenant as an example. He insists that the same principles apply to his own day, arguing that Christian rulers stand in the place of the Jewish kings, and that it is their duty to ensure the fulfillment of God's Law .Mornay proposes that if the ancient Jews were enjoined to resist godless rulers, the same must surely hold for Christians . Mornay stipulates that it is the duty of the people to safeguard pure worship. When dealing with this issue, then, Mornay insists that the question of idolatry is of prime importance, particularly because the violation of "pure worship" and the persecution of the true Church are the principal grounds for resistance... Peter Martyr echoed this sentiment in 1554, writing "wherefore for as much as idolatry is the cause of captivity, pestilence, and famine, and overthrowing of publique wealthes, shall it not pertaine unto the Magistrate to repress it, and to keep the true sound religion?" (Commentary on Judges , 1564 ed., fold. 266v-267r). From: War Against The Idols: The Reformation of Worship from Erasmus to Calvin by Carlos M. N. Eire (pp. 298-299, 300 [n89]), Cambridge University Press, 1986, emphases added (War Against The Idols is on sale at http://www.swrb.com/catalog/e.htm )+ Hundreds of books, MP3s and videos on the biblical (Reformation, Covenanter) view of civil government, civil resistance, worship, etc. are on SWRB's PURITAN HARD DRIVE .
+ Hundreds of books, MP3s and videos on the biblical (Reformation, Covenanter) view of civil government, civil resistance, worship, etc. are on SWRB's PURITAN HARD DRIVE .
Our Blog
-- recent blog posts -- 11/26/2024 - Overcoming Lust, Pornography & Other... 11/25/2024 - Bible Reveals the Truth About Dragons &... 11/24/2024 - Are Aliens Actually Demons? UFOs, UFO,... 11/24/2024 - Puritan & Reformed Postmillennial &... 11/23/2024 - Who Is the Beast of Revelation & 666?... 11/23/2024 - Why Many More People Will Be Saved Than... 11/23/2024 - Why God Judges the Church & the... 11/23/2024 - Rise Of Antichrist In History & the... 11/22/2024 - Biblical Civil Government Versus... 11/22/2024 - Best Free Reformed Audio Commentaries... 11/22/2024 - Abortion Is Murder, Democrats &... 11/22/2024 - HISTORY OF HOLY DAYS,... 11/21/2024 - In Praise & Defence of Motherhood,... 11/21/2024 - IF YOU NEGLECT DAILY FAMILY... 11/20/2024 - JOHN CALVIN & OTHER REFORMERS... 11/19/2024 - Defeating Demonic & Pagan Sexual... 11/19/2024 - Easter, Christian or Pagan/Papal? (Free... 11/18/2024 - Blasting the Devil's Lies About Sex,... 11/18/2024 - OVERCOMING LUST, SEXUAL SINS... 11/17/2024 - What Is The Gospel; The Heart of the... 11/17/2024 - SINGING PSALMS AND THE UNITY... 11/16/2024 - Regeneration, Salvation & Man's Will In... 11/16/2024 - Life From Non-Life An Evolutionary... 11/15/2024 - Easter, Christ-Mass (Christmas), Etc.,... 11/15/2024 - Antichrist & the Mystery of Iniquity... 11/14/2024 - Sexual Immorality, Lust & Stupid... 11/13/2024 - BIRTHDAYS: PAGAN/OCCULT... 11/12/2024 - Instrumental Music in Public Worship:... 11/11/2024 - Four Aspects of the Counter... 11/11/2024 - Biblical Prophecy, Pastor Jim Dodson,... 11/10/2024 - Postmillennialism, Free Reformation... 11/09/2024 - Why Preach Or Pray If All Things Are... 11/08/2024 - New Proof Demonic Democrats Committed... 11/08/2024 - Shocking Free Sermons About Hell;... 11/07/2024 - Effective Pastoral Preaching With Many... 11/06/2024 - Westminster Standards Are Part Of the... 11/05/2024 - Kamala (Democrat) described as an... 11/05/2024 - Vile hatred: Kamala’s anti-Christ... 11/04/2024 - FBI Allegedly Seize Diddy Tape Of... 11/01/2024 - Kamala Kicks Christians Out Her Rally... 10/27/2024 - Christ Is King Of the Nations! Great... 10/24/2024 - UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT... 10/20/2024 - Democrats Legalize Decapitating Babies,... 10/19/2024 - The Subjection of Kings & Nations to... 10/17/2024 - Abortion Is Murder - Biden & Democrats... 10/12/2024 - The Rise of Antichrist & the Corruption... 10/05/2024 - First of the Four Horsemen of the... 09/30/2024 - ARMINIAN/JESUIT PERSECUTION... 09/16/2024 - Biblical (Puritan, Reformed,... 08/31/2024 - A Jesuit: Our Foundation Is... 08/24/2024 - Perfect Fulfillments Of Prophecies, In... 08/16/2024 - Is Popery the Antichrist? or The... 08/13/2024 - Westminster Assembly, Exclusive... 07/22/2024 - Arminianism In Worship Is Idolatry,... 07/12/2024 - Puritan Quotes On God's Glory In... 07/06/2024 - Reformation, Restoration Prophets:... 06/30/2024 - Prophecy shows that a time is coming... 06/16/2024 - Calvin Reformation Quotes: How Modern... 05/31/2024 - Recent Creation Is A Vital Doctrine By... 05/15/2024 - Is Arminianism A Damnable Heresy?... 05/11/2024 - Puritan Quotes & Donation To Spread... 03/14/2024 - How Satan Uses VIDEO GAMES To Push Sin,... 02/29/2024 - Covenanting In the Bible & the Future,... 02/28/2024 - Movies, TV, the Web & Christian... 02/26/2024 - JONATHAN EDWARDS ON THE... 02/24/2024 - FREE ONLINE PURITAN &... 02/22/2024 - THE PURITAN HOPE, REVIVAL &... 02/19/2024 - John Flavel, John Calvin, Thomas... 02/16/2024 - WHY JOHN 3:16 REFUTES... 02/14/2024 - You Ought Not to Rest Ignorant &... 02/08/2024 - GODLY GOALS OF THE W... 01/30/2024 - Foundation for Reformation: The... 01/25/2024 - Christ's Mediatorial Reign, 5 Free... 01/11/2024 - Perfect Historical Fulfillments,... 01/08/2024 - The Rise of Antichrist and the... 01/06/2024 - Jonathan Edwards, Classic Reformed... 01/05/2024 - Why Many More People Will Be Saved Than... 01/03/2024 - CHRISTMAS: FREE BOOKS, MP3s & Videos By... 12/30/2023 - The Biblical Way To Eradicate Idols... 12/28/2023 - DO DEMONS LOVE CHRISTMAS? - Mather,... 12/27/2023 - Detesting Idols, Satanic Snares, Like... 12/26/2023 - Reformed Quotes Against the Celebration... 12/25/2023 - Easter, Christ-Mass (Christmas), Etc.... 12/24/2023 - How Christmas Idolatry Corrupts,... 12/24/2023 - Christmas Is Part Of Roman Catholic,... 12/24/2023 - CALVIN ON SEPARATION FROM... 12/19/2023 - Against Christmas and Easter, Pagan &... 12/17/2023 - Reformed Worship Quotes By Calvin,... 12/13/2023 - Idols, Idolatry, Iconoclasm, In... 12/13/2023 - Elliott's Commentary on the Apocalypse... 12/03/2023 - ATTRIBUTES OF GOD, FREE MP3s, Stephen... 11/26/2023 - ARMINIANISM ANOTHER GOSPEL:... 11/24/2023 - Has Jesuit Eschatology Overtaken... 11/22/2023 - We Must All Appear Before the Judgment... 10/26/2023 - MERRY CHRISTMAS SAYS THE... 07/17/2023 - Judgment of the Secrets of Men By... 06/19/2023 - God delights as much in the glory of... 04/24/2023 - The very beholding of Christ is a... 03/14/2023 - Exclusive Psalmody, Greg Price, 7 Free... 03/11/2023 - The Day of Judgment Asserted (Puritan... 03/04/2023 - Overcoming All Discouragements: God's... 02/22/2023 - Refuting The Arminian Heresy, The... 02/12/2023 - How Sexual Orientation Became the Idol... 02/09/2023 - The Lord Jesus Christ's Coming... 02/07/2023 - DR. VODDIE BAUCHAM REVIEWS... 01/16/2023 - Hath God appointed any other set times... 12/25/2022 - Christmas: Puritan, Reformed &... 12/21/2022 - Did Charles Spurgeon Celebrate... 12/20/2022 - Easter Quotes, Christmas Quotes,... 12/12/2022 - Birth Control: Biblical, Historic... 11/24/2022 - Cornerstone of Reformation With Which... 11/15/2022 - The Law of God, Holiness, Personal... 11/15/2022 - Christmas: Reformed, Covenanter &... 11/09/2022 - Calvinist Must Listen! How Christmas... 11/02/2022 - BIBLICAL JUSTIFICATION CONTRA... 10/24/2022 - Please Pray For the Ministry Of SWRB... 10/21/2022 - MANY FREE ONLINE PURITAN,... 10/15/2022 - What Is the Gospel? By Al Martin, 3... 10/09/2022 - Refuting Evolution, Handbook for... 10/04/2022 - Free Reformation Resources Defending... 09/30/2022 - $600 OFF PURITAN HARD DRIVE,... 08/10/2022 - No Compromise Between Calvinism &... 08/02/2022 - Imprecatory Prayer, Reprobation & God's... 07/16/2022 - Mathematician, Astrophysicist Debunks... 07/12/2022 - Heaven, What Is It Like? Joy's Eternal... 07/08/2022 - $600 OFF PURITAN HARD DRIVE... 07/04/2022 - Heresy Of Free Will In Salvation, by... 07/01/2022 - Contemplation of God: Thinking of His... 06/30/2022 - 357 Free MP3s By Jonathan Edwards, With... 06/13/2022 - What the Bible Means When It Says God... 06/08/2022 - Powerful Free Video! The Master... 05/25/2022 - PREMILLENNIALISM & A... 05/20/2022 - History Of Jesuit Wickedness & the... 05/17/2022 - Reprobates Bring Upon Themselves... 05/14/2022 - A Fantastic Free (MP3) Sermon On... 05/12/2022 - Louisiana Legislators Pass Bill Making... 05/11/2022 - Why Preach Or Pray If All Things Are... 05/05/2022 - Do & Teach God's Moral Law & You Shall... 04/29/2022 - Persecution & Why It Is A Great Honor... 04/26/2022 - The Sovereignty Of the Holy Spirit (&... 04/24/2022 - Against Godless Games, Ungodly Movies,... 04/23/2022 - God's Knowledge, God's Omniscient. He... 04/18/2022 - In Praise & Defense of Marriage,... 04/11/2022 - Demon Possession: Satanism, Sorcery,... 04/10/2022 - Instructions For Comforting Afflicted... 04/09/2022 - Of Heaven - Heaven Unimaginably... 04/07/2022 - The Torments of Hell Are Exceeding... 04/04/2022 - John Wesley Hated Calvinism &... 04/01/2022 - Discourse On Communion With God by John... 03/31/2022 - What Atheists Say Just Before Entering... 03/28/2022 - The Glory of God In the Face Of the... 03/26/2022 - Those prayers God likes best come... 03/25/2022 - Holiness Of God By Paul Washer, Dr.... 03/21/2022 - Evolution Is Inherently Racist,... 03/20/2022 - The Federal Vision is Still Heresy -... 03/18/2022 - What Are The Signs Of God's Judgment On... 03/16/2022 - Best Series Of Free Sermons About... 03/14/2022 - 10 Commandments: A Guide for Living, By... 03/13/2022 - Charles Spurgeon: To Deny Calvinism Is... 03/10/2022 - Furnace of Sanctification Through... 03/08/2022 - Wicked Cast Into Hell's Furnace of... 02/28/2022 - Free Reformed Commentaries On... 02/27/2022 - Many Free Puritan MP3s, Reformed... 02/23/2022 - Creation Vs. Evolution: E. Coli’s... 02/22/2022 - Free: John Knox's Against Romish Rites... 02/19/2022 - Providence & How God Turns Crosses &... 02/14/2022 - Dr. Reg Barrow Debates Doug Wilson; The... 01/18/2022 - OLIVER CROMWELL: PERSECUTOR... 11/16/2021 - Free: A Prophecy of the Increase of... 10/22/2021 - A Glimpse Into the Infinite Mind Of God... 09/15/2021 - Comfort in Sickness and Death (Free... 09/05/2021 - The Privilege of Prayer & How Get... 09/02/2021 - The Biblical Doctrine of Justification... 08/31/2021 - Westminster Confession, Calvin, Knox,... 08/30/2021 - Supremacy of God, By A.W. Pink;... 08/26/2021 - Church History Quotes Against... 08/24/2021 - "It is a pitiful thing, to be contented... 08/24/2021 - Martin Luther Quote Against... 08/22/2021 - John Calvin On Biblical Separation... 08/21/2021 - R.L. Dabney (Presbyterian) Quote... 08/20/2021 - Covenanted Reformation Quote:... 08/15/2021 - SWRB Puritan Quote Videos, Much Free;... 08/14/2021 - Lectures Upon the Principal Prophecies... 08/10/2021 - Martin Luther Quote Against Organs,... 07/30/2021 - Puritan Quotes, Reformed Quotations &... 07/28/2021 - Many Puritan, Reformed & Covenanter... 05/17/2021 - Instrumental Music In Public Worship... 04/13/2021 - What is God? Phenomenal Free MP3 By... 04/11/2021 - Tim Keller's Evolution Heresy; Refuting... 04/09/2021 - Many Free Puritan, Covenanter &... 04/08/2021 - What Lenin Said About Christians and... 03/23/2021 - JOHN WESLEY HATED THE... 12/31/2020 - Irrefutable Proof Of Massive Election... 11/15/2020 - BANNED VIDEO: MUST WATCH! Democrat's... 11/03/2020 - Trump Expands Order Defunding Planned... 10/27/2020 - Bombshell Interview Exposes... 10/10/2020 - Russia's Putin Praises Ideological... 10/01/2020 - The Pope Encourages Prayer To Allah;... 10/01/2020 - Donald Trump, Republican, Versus Joe... 09/29/2020 - Commiefornia (California) Tyranny V....
Older
Newer
Top